A Soliloquy of Sorts

A Brief List of Films in Which People of Color Are The First (or Only) to Die

We all know the trope: The person(s) of color (overwhelmingly the black guy) gets killed off first, especially in a horror film. Well here is a brief list of such films, many of which not only feature the person of color dying first, but feature the main white characters ultimately saving the day:

  • X-Men: First Class
  • King Kong
  • Scream 2
  • Predator (1 & 2)
  • Serenity
  • State of Play
  • Deep Rising
  • Kill Bill: Volume I
  • Jaws: The Revenge
  • House of Wax
  • Alien Vs. Predator: Requiem
  • Stargare
  • Aliens
  • The Shining
  • Leviathan
  • Terminator (1 & 2)
  • Red Dawn
  • Jurassic Park
  • Gremlins
  • Hollow Man
  • Hulk
  • Predators
  • United 93
  • Fantastic Four: Rise of the Silver Surfer
  • Super 8
  • Cursed
  • Killjoy
  • Queen of the Damned
  • Transformers (Not a complete fit in the trope since it’s not human-based. The only autobot to die in the film is Jazz, the jive-talking autobot voiced by a black actor)
  • 300
  • Resident Evil
  • The Mummy (1 & 2)

And believe me, I could probably find many more if I looked a little harder. (Feel free to correct me on any films, as I have not seen a few of these films).

So, what is the point of this list? Well, it’s to illustrate that even if at first glance, a film may show potential of diversity, people of color are still, in many respects, disposable in films. It’s just enough time to introduce the idea that these films are inclusive by introducing some racial diversity, yet allows them not to have to explore the nuances of these characters of color by killing them off, to focus on the true protagonists - the white folks.

Now, let me make it clear: the individual films listed are not necessarily racist because the feature this trope, and the reasoning for killing of the character of color might not be a conscious choice. Rather, the focus is how the overall trope itself is racist, as it is evident in several films that even if there are people of color in films, they are likely to be killed off or rid of early on, further illustrating Hollywood’s penchant for not telling stories of people of color in any meaningful way and only actively engaging a white-centered audience.

rosaflora:

US actor Danny Glover, who plans an epic next year on Haitian independence hero Toussaint-Louverture, said he slaved to raise funds for the movie because financiers complained there were no white heroes.

“Producers said ‘It’s a nice project, a great project… where are the white heroes?’” he told the press during a stay in Paris this month for a seminar on film.

“I couldn’t get the money here, I couldn’t get the money in Britain. I went to everybody. You wouldn’t believe the number of producers based in Europe, and in the States, that I went to,” he said.

D”The first question you get, is ‘Is it a black film?’ All of them agree, it’s not going to do good in Europe, it’s not going to do good in Japan.

“Somebody has to prove that to be a lie!”, he said. “Maybe I’ll have the chance to prove it.”

“Toussaint,” Glover’s first project as film director, is about Francois Dominique Toussaint Louverture (1743-1803), a former slave and one of the fathers of Haiti’s independence from France in 1804, making it the first black nation to throw off imperial rule and become a republic.

The uprising he led was bloodily put down in 1802 by 20,000 soldiers dispatched to the Caribbean by Napoleon Bonaparte, who then re-established slavery after its ban by the leaders of the French Revolution.

Due to be shot in Venezuela early next year, the film will star Don Cheadle, Mos Def, Wesley Snipes and Angela Bassett.

WOAH WOAH WOAH…A film about black people…being oppressed by white people…and those black people are helped…by other black people?!?! WOOAHHHHHH

(Source: fuckyeahmarxismleninism)

Also, Let me Make One Thing Clear

About my White Savior Films post:

I’m not against the individual films I’ve put on the list, because I actually like some of these films. Freedom Writers was one of my favorite films, and Finding Forrester was one of my favorite films I’ve seen in school.

My position against White Savior Films is not necessarily about the films as individuals, but the trend of the White Savior Complex within the group of films, and really, within Hollywood itself. I would like to see more films like Lean on Me rather than another Freedom Writers. More films like Coach Carter rather than another Glory Road, and etc.

It’s not like people of color aren’t telling stories about their own communities without the intervention of white folks. They are, and always have and always will. It’s about the fact that our society, and by reflection, Hollywood, put more value and attention onto White Savior stories, and that is the issue. It’s not the films themselves, but why those films are being made and getting so much more attention, and more importantly, why more films solely about people of color are not being made.

A Brief List and Analysis of White Savior Films

A White Savior Film (WSF) is a movie that features a white person coming into the lives of a person or people of color (POCs) who are often low-income, troubled, and/or severely oppressed. The troubled times that the people of color are in can be a product of oppression from other white folks, or their own doing. Either way, the White Savior comes in, quickly sympathizes with the problems of the people of color, learning what needs to happen to solve their problems, and in doing so, wins their favor and becomes their hero. Here is a list of some of these films:

  • Gran Torino
  • Avatar (Jake Sully literally becomes the Messiah of the Na’vi)
  • The Blind Side*
  • Hardball
  • The Ghosts of Mississippi*
  • Glory Road*
  • Dances With Wolves
  • Finding Forrester
  • The Principal*
  • Music of the Heart*
  • To Kill a Mockingbird (slightly on the fence with this one because the savior Atticus Finch does not save Tom Robinson from being convicted)
  • Radio*
  • Cool Runnings*
  • Dangerous Minds* (This film was based on the true story of a Latina teacher, yet Michelle Pfiffer played the teacher, thereby turning this into a WSF)
  • The Last Samurai
  • Wildcats
  • Freedom Writers*
  • Amistad*
  • Black Rain
  • Sunset Park
  • District 9 (Also slightly on the fence with this one since the white protagonist mainly follows the plan of the oppressed alien that stands for a POC, and he is more of an anti-hero)
  • Mississippi Burning*
  • The Last Airbender (the TV series composed of all Asian characters, but the film’s three main heroes were cast as white people, while everyone else was of color)
  • Dune
  • Glory*
  • The Ron Clark Story*
  • The Help
  • Atlantis: The Lost Empire
  • The Road to El Dorado

There are a few different kinds of WSF. The most popular kinds include the white teacher/administrator that helps the students of color realize their true potential and help them overcome their own prejudices (The Principal, Freedom Writers, Dangerous Minds, etc.), and the white sports coach leading his or her team filled with usually poor and troubled people of color to victory (Glory Road, Cool Runnings, Wildcats, Sunset Park, Hardball, etc).

The more epic, and true “savior” WSF that many sci-fi films also fit into feature a white person who is often an oppressor happening upon a culture of people of color or aliens that are POC stand-ins. The white hero eventually assimilates into their culture, and he even proves to be more skillful than them as learns the culture. He becomes their leader and savior in the battle against their enemies (Avatar, The Last Samurai, Dances With Wolves, Dune, District 9, etc.) Particularly for the “epic” WSF, the saviors are male, heterosexual, and very masculine.

So what are the problems with these films? Well, they portray people of color as too desolate, too hopeless, too overcome by their own prejudices and circumstances to help themselves, so they need someone to help them. But not just anyone, no, this helper must be a White Savior. This Savior inspires the people of color, teaches them how to be a better them, and makes their lives better when the people of color couldn’t do it themselves. These films ignore the stories of people of color helping their own communities and helping themselves.

Hollywood, and many white people, eat these WSF up because white audiences can identify wanting to be the “savior” in POC’s lives, to be the one who rescues the poor POCs from their circumstances, to be the hero in their lives. They help alleviate feelings of white guilt by projecting white people not as the oppressors, but as the heroes who can save people of color from their circumstances, and often, the oppression that whites in the past have caused. Essentially, these films capitalize on the stories of people of color, yet instead of telling the film through their eyes, they are presented as stories of the white people who help them. The people of color in these films function as catalysts for the White Savior to learn his or her lessons and reach the end of his or her own journey.

* You’ve probably noticed that many of these films are inspired by true stories. People who defend WSF often bring up the fact that several of these are “based on a true story,” however, that doesn’t necessarily mean that all WSF are valid as a group. Rather, it shows that Hollywood has a greater interest in the stories of heroic white people saving people of color than stories of people of color helping their own communities or people of color helping white people out of bad situations. WSF stories are being used to support the status quo.

Is it racist to enjoy these films? No, it’s not. You can still watch these films and like them, but they are part of a trend that chooses to ignore the perspective of people of color, and feed into the White Savior Complex that really shows what Hollywood, and unfortunately, many white people have, so choose your films well and watch them carefully.